Reviews from

Just a rose

Rose i crystal bowl

64 total reviews 
Comment from RedRockArt


It really fits the Title.
The quality is a five. When photographing glass, photographers use a tent. A good way of creating one, is with an old sheet. Cut a hole in it, put the lens through and hold it on with a rubber band. Prop it up in the sides of your subject, and shine lights through the sheet. It eliminates a lot of the specular highlights. Which take attention away from the rose.

Your idea of less is more, is excellent. With lots of roses or anything else, "you dont see the rose, due to the forest." :)

Keep originals, practice working with a good editor like Photoshop or Lightroom and in a year you could be amazed at what you could do with the same original. Ive been going over my old shots, some from 20 years ago. Technology was not as advanced then, they make much more impact today.

It looks really good on my monitor which is calibrated for printing on Fuji papers, so it should make a really good print.

It has a Impact.

It has a good tonal range, from blacks without detail to detail in the shadows, bright colors and white, to specular highlight in zone 10.

Good composition, with strong point of interest in content.

You might improve it, with some post processing and sharpening. With digital, we lose sharpness in processing. A final sharpening might really make this pop. BUT, if you like the softer atmosphere, leave it alone.

 Comment Written 28-Nov-2010


reply by the author on 28-Nov-2010
    Thank you very much, I cannot shatpen it more yhan I have done. It just gets grainy
Comment from virginian


Nice shot of bowl and rose. The simplicity of it makes the shot. Like the bowl reflections. Nice fading, colors, clarity and good rose details. 'Enjoyed.

 Comment Written 28-Nov-2010


reply by the author on 28-Nov-2010
    Thank you very much
reply by virginian on 28-Nov-2010
    You are welcome.
Comment from RagsAuggie


A Lovely rose! I like the way you framed it in a glass looking bowl! Good color and lighting and details! Thanks for sharing! Cindy

 Comment Written 28-Nov-2010


reply by the author on 28-Nov-2010
    Thank you very much
Comment from marieann green


Not just a rose
A very beautifully composed rose
Nicely done
I see that you are experimenting or is it just too cold to go outside?
Great technical expertise
Enjoyed


 Comment Written 28-Nov-2010


reply by the author on 28-Nov-2010
    Thank you very much. Answer: Both, Today it is a snow storm outside and it is bitterly cold. I hate the winter