FanStory.com - Reviews For Moonlight Sleep

Reviews from

Moonlight Sleep

for contest

30 total reviews

Comment from Carmen Ducharme

This is a lovely picture and I see many things through your beautiful image .A lovely girl lying in bed with dreams of being free like a mermaid to live under the moon and stars what a lovely dream and beautiful way to display it through your picture ! Thank you for sharing - Carmen :)

Comment Written 10-Sep-2021

reply by the author on 12-Sep-2021

Thanks for the great review

Comment from Aunty Jan

Looks like a mermaid!
Nice picture of a good sleep. Like it was done from the view of a skylight. Since it is in greys and whites, it has a dreamlike quality to it.
Also, the video was interesting and thoughtful.

Comment Written 10-Sep-2021

reply by Anonymous Member on 10-Sep-2021

I forgot to add that I think the angels are guarding her sleep.

reply by Aunty Jan on 11-Sep-2021

you are welcome

Comment from Donna Colley

I love the look of the window and looking in on her threw the window. Not to much detail but enough for the style of this piece. The thing that is sticking in my mind is the "legs" under the blanket...is it her legs or maybe a mermaid tail? Either way, it's well done!

This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.

Comment Written 10-Sep-2021

reply by the author on 10-Sep-2021

Oh Donna Donna Donna! I do realize that your a newbie. I know that you dont realize that a 2 star rating translate that this work sux and needs to start over again. No matter what you say the 2 star says it all. Now other members would be upset and remember what YOU review they also review YOURS as well. Now this skit from my cartoon of a view thru a skylight window while the moon is beaming onto this girl laying in bed. Clearly can one see it is shadows on the cover. Not to worry about me being mad..many newbies like yourself have to stumble to learn..wink..thanks for the poor review

Comment from Regina E.H-Ariel

Wow - what a position - totally unusual and again a very special idea - fantastic detail work in composition, in all different parts coming together in perfect harmony - This is a private situation but fantastic to see the harmonious girl or lady in her sleeping position - the black and white is attractive in this composition - perfect contrast and light application, well done again, making me smile

Comment Written 10-Sep-2021

reply by the author on 12-Sep-2021

Thanks for the great review

reply by Regina E.H-Ariel on 12-Sep-2021

You are most welcome

Comment from Glena Jessee-King

It is a nice black and white entry, however, not quite as perfect as so most of your work is. Your video is so able and good as usual so I gave a "5". As I view your drawing more, it becomes nicer and nicer to me. Great job in your drawing too.

Comment Written 08-Sep-2021

reply by the author on 12-Sep-2021

Thanks for the good review

reply by Glena Jessee-King on 14-Sep-2021

Welcome.

Comment from iPhone7

Hey Red Leg. It has been a while since I was on here. Kind of hit a wall in creativity and 'seeing' potential scenes. Kind of a photographic block as it were.

Back down in Mexico. Considering moving here next year.

Good to see you are still cranking out great works and getting the recognition you deserve. Keep on kicking azz and taking names ~ Top

Comment Written 03-Jul-2021

reply by the author on 05-Jul-2021

Oh yeah. Miles to go before i sleep..wink..thanks Top for the great review

Comment from Tootie H2O

This is so cool! To view through a window makes it feel so real, I feel like I'm watching this sweet kid peacefully sleep. Drawing details are excellent. Well done

Comment Written 03-Jul-2021

reply by the author on 05-Jul-2021

Thanks Tootie for the great review

Comment from Brenda Curley

This is peaceful and relaxing art to view! ( No pun intended.) I like the angle of this female as she slumbers. The bedspread is so appropriate and dreamlike.
The details throughout are very well executed.
I enjoy the perspective of looking down through the window. Creative and well done.
PS I appreciate your response
here stating the guidelines of reviewing. Reviewers need to be objective not subjective done by those with much experience.

Comment Written 02-Jul-2021

reply by the author on 03-Jul-2021

true..voting contest some members will vote for the person and not the work..that's why some feel that blind contest is the only true fair contest. i hate to break it to them but when you review as much work as i have, i can recognize many works right off the bat. me personally im not getting into blind contests. the only reason is im not putting my copyright work out there without my logo signature
on it. so that is the real reason you dont see me in those..wink. thanks for the awesome review.

Comment from TDtraditionalart

I really like this piece. It makes me wonder what she is dreaming about. A great story telling aspect here. The uniform outline of the window has a calming effect for the viewer. The choice of bedspread is bold, it must have taken a long time. I like the perspective you chose. Over all a great piece, good luck in the contest!

Comment Written 02-Jul-2021

reply by the author on 02-Jul-2021

im not just a cartoonist but yeah im a illustrator as well. i have to be ready to create a story of anything for the writer or songwriter comes up with..yes i do music videos too. you can find them on youtube..wink. thanks for the great review.

Comment from DMacKay

I love seeing moon shadows! In my view, they always portray a beautiful, peaceful scene. I appreciate the interesting details on the quilt. Very nice work!